Subscribe to our newsletter, get our FREE ebook.

* indicates required
Close

Grilled New York Strip Steak

New York Strip is one of our favorite steaks to grill.  Grill recipes for steak don’t get any easier than this!  As with grilling filet mignon, less is more when grilling new york strip steaks.  The best way to grill these kinds of steaks is over direct high heat.  This method seals in the juices and cooks the steak quickly, not allowing the steak to dry out.  Below are step by step instructions on how to grill a new york strip steak.

Grill Method: Direct grilling over high heat with the lid open.
Grilling Time: About 8 minutes total for a 1″ thick New York Strip steak.

Ingredients:
New York Strip Steak
Garlic Salt
Fresh Ground Pepper

Directions:

  1. Approximately 45 minute before you are ready to grill your new york strip steaks, take them out of the fridge and rub in some garlic salt and fresh ground pepper. Leave them on the counter to let them warm to room temperature.
  2. Preheat the grill on high for direct grilling.
  3. Clean your grill with a grill brush.
  4. Hold your hand about 2 inches above the grill and see if the temperature is right. For gas grilling steaks over high heat, you don’t want to be able to hold your hand over the grill for more than 5 seconds. Don’t try to be tough, you know when it is hot!
  5. Place the new york strip steaks on the grill with tongs. NEVER pierce the skin of the steaks with a fork!
  6. After about 2 minutes, use tongs to pick up the steaks, rotate 90 degrees and then place the steaks back on the grill for those nice grill marks.
  7. After 2 more minutes, you are ready to flip the steaks. Pick them up and flip them over. This is the only time you are going to flip the steaks (we told you this was easy).
  8. After another 2 minutes, rotate the new york strip steaks another 90 degrees.
  9. Now grill them for a final 2 minutes and they should be ready.  Take the grilled steaks off the grill and let them rest for at least 5 minutes before serving.  You can always stick them back on the grill for a few minutes if they aren’t done enough.

Tips on Grilling Steaks Number 1, How to tell a Strip Steak is Done:
In our post on how to grill filet mignon, we discussed how to tell if the steaks were ready by pushing on the steaks.  Again, we NEVER want to cut into our steaks or pierce the steaks in any way.  This same technique applies to New York Strip steaks, but you can also tell if they are done another way.  When you first picked up the raw steaks with tongs to place on the grill, they were pretty limp, right?  When you grill a steak, the flesh gets firm.  So a medium grilled thinner steak, like a strip or a ribeye should bend a little when picked up with tongs, but will be more firm than when raw.  The more rigid the steak, the more well done!  It will take a little practice, but you should be able to tell with this “rigid steak” test after observing a few times.

Serve your grilled new york strip steaks with some grilled vegetables or a nice baked potato and enjoy!  Remember, some of your guests might not be red meat eaters.  In that case, make sure you have some nice grilled chicken breasts to satisfy all of your guests.

20 Responses

avatar

Doug Francis

07-23-2010

Thanks for the advice. Just picked up NY Strip that’s about 1 1/2″ thick, bone-in… will adjust times a minute.

avatar

TJ

06-06-2011

my last grill used a cast iron grate. i was produce phenominal grill marks with the cast iron. my new kenmore grill has a porcelain coated steel cooking surface. im yet to produce great grill marks with it. am I not preheating enough or is this normal with this type of surface. NY strip is my favorite cut and I pride myself on the grill marks :)

avatar

David

11-04-2011

Grilling Companion, I bought a nice grass fed strip steak and followed your grilling directions. They produced the most phenomenal steak I’ve ever made. One of the best I’ve ever had. Served with roasted beets, asparagus, and cloves of garlic. Incredible meal. Thanks for the great grilling advice!!

avatar

Jonas

02-10-2012

Finally…grilled 3/4″ New York Steak so tender and delicious!! I used olive oil rub as well. Thanks

avatar

Amber

02-13-2012

Just made these tonight. Some of the best steak ive ever had!! Delicious!

avatar

Shanon

02-17-2012

Thanks! Super quick and easy! Family loved it!

avatar

Eric

03-11-2012

I’m assuming this is all done with the lid open (similar to your filet instructions).
can you confirm?

avatar

Mitch Cholewinski

07-06-2012

I get my grill heat up to 550 hot but if I keep the lid open the heat drops way down, no more high heat.Is it ok to just keep the lid down and follow your directions? I did this with fish and it came out ok.

avatar

KeithFullerMusic.com

08-21-2012

worked wonderfully. the thinner one might be better suited at about 1:45 per turn/flip if you want it medium rare. in the world of grilled steaks – seconds make a world of difference.

avatar

CJ

08-28-2012

Finally!!!!! I cooked a great steak for the first time without having to cut it open to check it !!! Thank you so much!

avatar

Sarah

11-11-2012

I tried your directions & they worked marvelously! I’m glad because my boyfriend is a chef & I like to impress him. I literally just got a grill tonight and surprised him with steaks when he got home from work (along with grilled zucchini & red pepper) and he loved it! Thanks a million.

avatar

Ray Jackson

06-09-2013

I have just eaten the best New York Steak I have ever had, And with your instructions, I prepared it.
The wind was blowing my flames a bit so I increased the grilling time 1 minute per side.
So much for saving half till breakfast, I ATE IT ALL.

Thank you so much.

Leave a Reply

Search Recipes By Category: